The new real estate agent commission law: Property sales and property rentals
Who pays the real estate agent's commission according to the new law? In this article, you will receive comprehensive information regarding the agent's commission. Since December 23, 2020, a new legal regulation regarding the agent's commission in real estate sales has been in effect. For the rental of real estate, the payment of the agent's commission has already been legally implemented since mid-2015 under the principle that the person who orders the service pays for it.
The most important facts about real estate agent commissions at a glance
For a successful brokerage activity in sales or leasing of a real estate property, a broker is entitled to remuneration. This is a fee that the broker receives for their successful work. Real estate brokers are hired for the sale, purchase, or rental of a property.
At Real estate for sale since December 23, 2020, the real estate agent's commission is split between the buyer and the seller. The client may at most half of the commission to the other party to the contract The amount of the commission is generally freely negotiable in real estate sales. Depending on the region, the total broker fee can range between three and seven percent of the purchase price plus statutory value-added tax. The notarized purchase price serves as the basis for calculating the broker fee. The payment is due upon conclusion of the purchase agreement, i.e., after notarization by the notary.
At Property rentals the "tenant pays the landlord's agent" principle applies, ensuring a uniform regulation for the payment of real estate agent commissions in residential rentals. The real estate agent is paid by the person who hired them. This is typically the landlord. The basis for calculating the agent's commission is the achieved monthly cold rent.
The Commission amount for rental properties is not prescribed by law. Usually it is two months' net cold rent plus value-added tax if the landlord has commissioned the real estate agent to rent out the property. If the tenant has commissioned the real estate agent to search for a property, the amount of the commission for the tenant is governed by the Housing Mediation Act (WoVermittG). The law prescribes a clear upper limit. It is 2 months' cold rent plus the statutory value-added tax.
Real estate agent commission on property sales
The real estate agent may issue a commission invoice as soon as a purchase agreement is concluded. Before the new legal regulation, the contracting parties were free to decide how to distribute the commission between the parties. Above all, the Customs and practices in the respective federal state were decisive in determining who was liable for commission. In some federal states, the splitting of the commission was already customary, in others the seller's commission was established, and in some regions the buyer's commission was more common.
Individual solutions regarding commission until December 23, 2020
The client and the broker were able to until December 23, 2020 make individual agreements regarding the division of commission. Depending on the situation, the buyer and the seller could negotiate with the broker on how to split the amount of the broker's commission for the real estate transaction. Basically, either a seller-paid commission or a buyer-paid commission was possible. When a seller-paid commission was agreed upon, the broker invoiced the seller exclusively for their service. If a buyer-paid commission was agreed upon, the real estate buyer paid the broker's costs in full.
The division of the commission was always determined by the customs in the respective federal state. In a very large number of federal states, it is customary for the broker's commission to be split equally between the parties.
New commission regulation as of December 23, 2020
As of December 23, 2020, a new „Act on the Distribution of Brokerage Costs for the Brokerage of Purchase Agreements for Apartments and Single-Family Houses“ has entered into force. This brings about standardization in the regulation of commissions. The legislature justifies the new regulation on the grounds that both the seller and the buyer benefit equally from the broker's activity. Since real estate prices, including ancillary purchase costs, have risen sharply primarily in metropolitan areas, buyers should be relieved financially when purchasing real estate.
This law regulates how the commission is to be split between the seller and the buyer. As a rule, the party who first commissions the real estate agent may at most half transfer the agreed broker's commission to the other contracting party. In practice, it is usually the seller who commissions the broker to mediate the sale of their property. Consequently, they must assume at least half of the commission. The broker may demand the remainder of the commission from the buyer. If both the seller and the buyer conclude a contract with the broker, both parties must pay the same share of the commission. If the broker grants a discount on the commission to the seller, the buyer must benefit from this equally.
This new legal regulation only applies if the Buyer as consumer acts. As a consumer, the buyer enters into a contract when purchasing a single-family home (including a semi-detached house or terraced house), a condominium, or a plot of land for their own private use. However, even if the real estate buyer purchases the property for private rental purposes, they act as a consumer and may pay a maximum of half of the broker's commission. In the event that the buyer acquires a property for commercial purposes, the broker's commission can be freely negotiated. Even if the buyer purchases an apartment building or an undeveloped plot of land, the sharing of the broker's commission is not affected by the new statutory regulation and can likewise be freely negotiated. Consumers who buy a plot of land for the construction of a home are also not affected by the sharing of the commission.
Who is a consumer?
Consumer is every natural person, who signed a contract to private purposes concludes (§ 13 BGB). In contrast to consumers, the entrepreneur is the one who concludes a contract as part of their commercial or independent professional activity (§ 14 BGB).
Internal or external commission when selling residential property
It is also possible, however, that only a party that covers the full broker commission. The broker and the seller can still agree on a pure real estate commission. This means that the seller assumes the entire commission (e.g. six percent of the purchase price plus value-added tax). A buyer's commission is also permissible, in which the buyer pays the broker a commission-based search request granted. The broker must first acquire the property and must not have it in their portfolio at the time of the commission.
Amount of commission varies by region
The legislator does not precisely stipulate how high the broker's commission may be. Depending on the federal state and region the commission is between three and seven percent plus value added tax. The basis for calculation is the notarized purchase price. In Bavaria The commission is typically 7.14 % in total, including statutory value-added tax. It is split equally between the seller and the buyer. Thus, the commission amounts to 3.57 % for each party.
Incidental purchase costs in real estate transactions
When financing, prospective buyers should not only keep an eye on the property price, but also on the additional purchase costs or acquisition costs. These consist of the real estate transfer tax, notary fees, and the real estate agent commission. Under certain circumstances, the real estate transfer tax may be reduced. Learn more about this here.
Real estate agent commission for rentals
Until June 2015, there were no statutory regulations regarding the broker's commission. In tight housing markets and for high-demand real estate, the brokerage fees were borne by prospective tenants. For properties that were difficult to rent out, the owner covered the broker's fee. Since June 1, 2015, the "whoever orders pays" principle has applied to the rental of residential real estate. The party that hires the broker pays the commission. In practice, this means that the broker's commission is usually paid by the landlord if he hired the broker.
It is not permissible to subsequently pass the commission on to the tenant. The Housing Mediation Act (WoVermittG) protects tenants from an inappropriate transfer of commission costs by declaring fee agreements invalid if they are in „gross disproportion to the value of the furnishing.“ Therefore, if the tenant is to pay compensation for existing items, this compensation must not exceed the actual value of the furnishing by more than 50 percent. If a tenant has wrongfully paid a broker's commission, they have a total of 3 years to reclaim the commission.
Commission Rate for Rentals
If a tenant hires a real estate agent to find a property, the maximum commission amount is regulated by law. According to the WoVermittG, it may not exceed two months’ base rent plus the applicable value-added tax. The real estate agent is free to negotiate the commission amount with the landlord for brokering the rental of residential space. The monthly base rent generally serves as the basis for the commission. The prospective tenant does not have to pay a commission after the lease is signed, as the real estate agent is compensated for their work by the landlord.
Contact us – we are always available
Commercial real estate and the commission rate
The amount of the real estate commission for commercial properties is fundamentally open to negotiation. There are no legal requirements regarding the commission rate, whether for rentals or sales.
Commercial Leasing
The "buyer-pays" principle does not apply to commercial real estate. How the real estate agent's commission is divided when leasing commercial properties depends on the property, its location, and market demand. In many cases, the landlord pays the entire commission. In addition, the Customs in the respective federal states as a guideline for determining the commission. If demand is very high, the commission may be split between the landlord and the tenant or passed on entirely to the tenant. The tenant may claim the real estate brokerage fees as a tax deduction.
The amount of the brokerage fee varies for commercial real estate. The longer the term of the commercial lease, the higher the broker’s commission. If a lease is signed for up to five years, the commission is three months’ rent. For a longer term, it is four months’ rent. The commission may be calculated based on either the gross monthly rent (base rent plus utilities) or the net monthly rent (base rent excluding utilities).
Commercial Real Estate Sales
Who pays the real estate agent's commission when selling a commercial property depends on, in which federal state where the property is located. In some countries, the commission is split equally between the buyer and the seller. For commercial properties, the amount of the broker’s fee is freely negotiable. According to the German Civil Code, the client may not be charged excessive fees (see prohibition against usury). Whether usury has occurred is determined by comparing the agreed-upon fees to customary fees (Federal Court of Justice, Case No.: IX ZR 121/99).
Can the broker commission be negotiated?
In general, buyers and sellers can discuss the amount of the commission with the real estate agent for properties for sale. However, this must be negotiated before the purchase agreement is signed. Once the agreement has been notarized, it is no longer possible.
Real estate in metropolitan areas is in high demand. Prospective buyers who are willing to pay the full commission will generally receive preference. If the property is difficult to market, a price reduction is more likely to be achieved. In the case of rentals, the real estate agent's commission is rarely negotiable, because the agent's costs are usually just about covered.
How is a broker contract concluded?
It is important for everyone involved to know how a real estate brokerage agreement should be drawn up. For rental properties, the agreement must include a clear commission arrangement generally in writing be concluded (see Section 2 of the Real Estate Brokerage Act). This may be done by letter, email, text message, or fax. An oral or telephone agreement between the owner and the real estate agent does not give rise to a claim for a brokerage commission.
For properties for sale, it was generally possible prior to December 23, 2020, to enter into a brokerage agreement even tacitly. This was done through so-called “implied” conduct. Although this was legally permissible, we have always informed all prospective buyers about the brokerage fee both verbally and in writing and required their consent. This is because it has always been important to clearly inform prospective buyers of all costs incurred in connection with the purchase of the property in question.
Effective December 23, 2020, the law requires that The real estate brokerage agreement must be in writing when an apartment or a single-family home (including semi-detached and townhouses) is sold to a consumer.. The contract must specify the amount of the brokerage fee. The real estate agent must therefore enter into a written contract with both the seller and the prospective buyer. The following written formats are acceptable: email, fax, text message, or WhatsApp. Verbal contracts or implied agreements are no longer permitted.
In a commercial context, the conclusion of contracts and commission agreements by a handshake or through other implied conduct is generally still permissible. However, even when brokering commercial spaces, we exclusively use brokerage contracts in text form to ensure clarity for everyone. Thus, the respective brokerage contract, including the commission agreement, forms the basis for the commission claim if the property is successfully brokered. Invoicing takes place after the real estate purchase contract has been concluded at the notary's office.
When you hire a real estate agent, they do not only conclude a brokerage agreement with you as the seller or landlord. However, the relationship between a broker and prospective buyers is also regulated. An agreement is concluded between the broker and the prospective buyers when they want to view an offered property. You are informed about the broker's terms and conditions and decide whether or not you wish to accept them. In practice, we also conclude a brokerage agreement in text form with prospective buyers as soon as they show closer interest in a property. In the agreement, the prospective buyer is clearly and comprehensibly informed about the commission arrangement. If the broker's fee is paid by both the buyer and the seller, it is considered dual agency. In doing so, the broker ensures that the interests of both parties are taken into account.
Brokerage entitlement and payment of the broker's commission
The real estate agent may not claim his commission until he has successfully completed the assignment. This means that, depending on the assignment, a purchase agreement, lease agreement, or rental agreement must have been signed (Section 652 of the German Civil Code (BGB)). In addition, the Brokerage activity was the causal factor for the conclusion of the contract . In practice, this means, for example, that the prospective buyer learns about the property from the real estate agent, conducts a viewing with the agent, or conducts contract negotiations through the agent.
If the property owner has found a buyer on their own, this generally does not give rise to a commission claim. However, it depends on the type of agreement the property owner has entered into with the real estate agent. This is because, under a qualified exclusive listing agreement, the owner is obligated to refer private prospective buyers to the real estate agent.
As reputable real estate agents, we work exclusively with the following in our brokerage activities: Qualified sole-source contracts. This offers advantages for both the owner and prospective buyers. The seller benefits from our full commitment to successfully marketing their property and from the discretion we maintain. Prospective buyers know exactly who to contact when they have a serious interest in a property. They can be certain that the property has not yet been reserved and that they are not wasting their time. Furthermore, overlapping viewing appointments are ruled out. Serious prospective buyers generally make sure that the real estate agent has an exclusive listing.
If the real estate agent has fulfilled his or her obligations and complied with all regulations, he or she may bill the agreed-upon fee.
Can the placement fee be deducted for tax purposes?
Under certain circumstances, the client may deduct the brokerage fee paid from their taxes. Landlord The costs for the real estate agent, as well as many other expenses related to the rental apartment, can be claimed as income-reducing expenses when filing File a claim with the tax office. Also Tenant can the placement fee as business expenses tax-deductible if the Relocation required for professional reasons was or if they a Second home for professional reasons need.
Property owners can deduct real estate agent fees from their taxes if the sale of a house or apartment results in a taxable capital gain results. This is the case, for example, with rented properties if they before the expiration of the ten-year speculation period sold. The broker's fee is one of the incidental acquisition costs associated with buying a house or apartment. If the buyer lives in the property themselves, they cannot deduct the broker's commission. However, if they rent out the property, they can buyer's brokerage fee written off for tax purposes become.
Share
Download as PDF
Print page
Would you like to know the value of your property? Free and without obligation.
Would you like to know the current value of your property? You've come to the right place for informed value assessments. Call us: 089 70065020.
Our property valuation for you:
- A high-quality and comprehensive analysis of your property.
- Well-founded real estate valuation including market analysis.
- Ideal for owners, sellers, and buyers.

