+49 (0)89 70065020
Geothermal heat pump: technology, costs, and funding opportunities
Geothermal heat pump: technology, costs, and funding opportunities
Geothermal heat pumps are like treasure hunters, utilizing the hidden warmth deep beneath the Earth's surface to heat your home. This heating method is particularly efficient because the temperature in the ground remains relatively constant throughout the year. It is like having a natural, steady heat source lying directly beneath our feet. However, installing a geothermal heat pump is comparable to creating a garden pond: before you can enjoy the benefits, there is quite a bit of work to be done first. The heat source must be tapped into, which means special technology is brought deep into the earth to harness geothermal energy. These initial investments are higher than with many other heating systems. In our article, we compare geothermal heat pumps with other types of heating and explore the question of whether the investment is truly worthwhile for homeowners. We want to help you understand whether this environmentally friendly heating method is the right choice for your home.
The miracle of geothermal energy beneath the Earth's surface
Imagine your home as a cozy nest, heated by an invisible, warm embrace of the Earth itself. This is not fantasy, but the reality of a geothermal heat pump—a heating system that taps into the constant, natural warmth directly beneath our feet. While winter rages outside and the cold bites, deep underground it remains pleasantly warm. This geothermal heat is like a reliable, green energy source just waiting to be used. And this is precisely where the geothermal heat pump comes into play, acting like a diligent helper that captures this warmth and transforms it into comfortable heating energy for your home.
A small power plant in the garden
The technology behind it is as fascinating as it is effective. Special probes or collectors that reach into the earth like the roots of a tree gather the heat. This is then absorbed and boosted by the heat pump, the heart of the system. Like a chef who tastes and warms up a soup, the pump raises the temperature of the heat to the perfect level so that your radiators or underfloor heating can provide you with comfort.
Contact us – we are always available
How a geothermal heat pump works: A cycle that generates heat in an environmentally friendly way
The inner workings of a geothermal heat pump are a small engineering marvel. A special refrigerant that changes its state of aggregation even at low temperatures and absorbs heat plays the main role. It slips through the evaporator, where it absorbs the heat from the earth, evaporates, and turns into a gas. Then it moves on to the compressor, which pressurizes the gas and makes it really hot—just right to warm your home. After the refrigerant has released its heat, it turns back into a liquid and the whole magic begins again. With this brief insight into the world of geothermal heat pumps, you can see that it's not just about technology, but a clever and environmentally friendly way to heat your home.
Collectors vs. Probes: Two ways to use the earth's heat
Geothermal heat pumps come in two variants that differ in the way they extract heat from the ground: geothermal probes and geothermal collectors, also known as geothermal baskets. Both have their advantages and specific features that make them ideal for different situations.
Deep down with geothermal probes
Geothermal probes reach deep beneath the Earth's surface, often between 40 and 100 meters deep, to access the constant heat that prevails at these depths. Already at a depth of 10 meters, the temperature remains steady at around 11 degrees Celsius, and with every additional depth of 30 meters, it rises by about 1 degree. These constant conditions allow the probes to operate very efficiently. Deep geothermal energy refers to particularly deep systems that reach more than 400 meters into the earth and achieve temperatures above 20 degrees. Although the installation of such probes is costly, the investment pays off through the high efficiency of the heating.
Distributed over a large area: horizontal ground collectors
On the other side are the geothermal collectors, which gather heat at a shallower depth, about 1.5 to 2 meters below the surface. These collectors are extensive pipe systems that must be laid over a large area below the frost line. The required space is about twice the size of the building to be heated, which makes them primarily attractive for new constructions where the garden has not yet been landscaped. The installation of collectors is less invasive and more cost-effective than that of probes, but it assumes that sufficient free space is available. In addition, factors such as the thermal conductivity of the soil, the water content, and the location of the property should be considered before installation. Both systems use the natural heat of the earth, but while probes work deeper and often more efficiently, collectors offer a viable solution for locations where sufficient space is available. The choice between probes and collectors ultimately depends on the geological conditions, the available space, and the budget.
The impressive efficiency of geothermal heating systems
Geothermal heating systems are true powerhouses when it comes to efficient heating. Imagine putting a single kilowatt-hour of electricity into a geothermal heating system and getting back up to five kilowatt-hours of heating energy—that is the impressive potential of this technology. In comparison, air-source heat pumps are the hardworking laborers that can still extract a remarkable 3.5 to 4 kilowatt-hours of heating energy from one kilowatt-hour of electricity. But geothermal heating systems often have the edge by utilizing the natural and constant heat of the ground to operate even more efficiently. However, the efficiency of a heat pump is not a rigid number. Rather, it is the result of an interplay of various factors, much like the ingredients of a recipe that together create the perfect taste. The insulation of your house and the supply temperature of your heating system, which are crucial for the heat pump's electricity consumption, are decisive here. A house that is not well insulated can dampen the efficiency of a heat pump, so that you might only get back twice the energy you put in in the form of heat.
Costs of a geothermal heat pump and funding opportunities
Geothermal heating systems are an investment in the future that may seem costly at first, but pay off in the long run. The total costs for such a heating system vary between 25,000 and 40,000 EUR. These high costs primarily result from the necessary earthworks and drilling required for the installation.
Comparison of costs between collectors and probes
When choosing between a horizontal ground collector and a vertical geothermal probe, the collector is the more cost-effective option. Without the need for deep drilling, the costs for collectors range between approximately 25,000 and 30,000 EUR. A system with probes, on the otherーム, can cost up to 40,000 EUR. For those looking for an even more affordable alternative, an air-to-water heat pump might be interesting, as this involves no extensive earthworks and the costs are consequently significantly lower.
Would you like to know the value of your property? Free and without obligation.
Would you like to know the current value of your property? You've come to the right place for informed value assessments. Call us: 089 70065020.
Our property valuation for you:
- A high-quality and comprehensive analysis of your property.
- Well-founded real estate valuation including market analysis.
- Ideal for owners, sellers, and buyers.
Use government subsidies to reduce the cost of heat pumps for efficient heating
Thanks to the federal government's current subsidy policy, the purchase costs for geothermal heating systems can be significantly reduced. The amendment to the Federal Funding for Efficient Buildings (BEG), which has been in effect since 2023, offers attractive grants for the purchase of heat pumps and other environmentally friendly heating systems. The KfW Program 458 includes basic funding as well as additional bonuses for speed, efficiency, and income-dependent factors.
Depending on the type of heating system, the timing of the replacement, and household income, the subsidy can amount to up to 85 % of the acquisition costs, although the subsidy rate is capped at a maximum of 70 % and the maximum eligible amount is 30,000 EUR. These financial incentives make investing in a geothermal heating system not only ecologically, but also economically attractive.
Geothermal heating vs. air-water heat pump: A comparison
When it comes to choosing between a geothermal heating system and an air-source heat pump, two different approaches to environmentally friendly home heating are up for debate. Both systems have their pros and cons that need to be considered.
Efficiency and operating costs
Geothermal heating systems, whether using probes or collectors, utilize the constant temperature of the ground, which generally makes them more efficient. The temperature beneath the earth's surface is less susceptible to fluctuations compared to the outside air used by air-source heat pumps. As a result, geothermal heating systems are often cheaper to operate, especially during the cold winter months.
Acquisition costs and installation
This shows a clear advantage for the air-source heat pump. While the installation of a geothermal heating system requires extensive earthworks that drive up costs, the air-source heat pump is much easier to install. For the air-source variant, only a suitable location needs to be found, whereas with geothermal heating, the suitability of the property and the geological conditions must also be checked. This may require deep drilling in the case of probes and presupposes a sufficiently large and suitable area in the case of collectors.
Complexity of planning in the development of the heat source
Planning a geothermal heating system is usually more complex. In addition to examining the soil conditions and the availability of sufficient space, it must also be considered that not every location is suitable for such an installation. This is especially true for older buildings, where retrofitting a geothermal heating system is often associated with significant disruptions to the existing garden layout.
Alternative: Groundwater heat pump
As a third option, there is also the groundwater heat pump, which works similarly to the geothermal probe, but directly uses groundwater as a heat source. However, this variant is rare because not only is it expensive to purchase, but it also requires a permit from the water authority and poses potential risks to the groundwater table. The decision between these systems ultimately depends on many individual factors, such as local conditions, the budget, and personal preferences regarding environmental friendliness and operating costs.
Amortization: When a geothermal heat pump really pays off
A geothermal heat pump is like a long-distance runner among heating systems: it starts with higher costs, but over the distance it scores points with its endurance and efficiency. Especially in a new build, it can quickly become a money saver. It not only offers the potential to lower heating costs, but also brings pleasant extras with it. For example, it can passively cool the house in summer, which makes the purchase of a separate air conditioning unit unnecessary.
Also, omitting the chimney or exhaust pipes saves costs and effort. In new construction, ground collectors can also be cleverly integrated into upcoming excavation work. But even in older buildings, retrofitting to a geothermal heat pump can be a smart decision. It often performs better than an air-source heat pump because it achieves higher seasonal performance factors and supplies more heat for the tends-to-be higher demand of older buildings – and at lower operating costs.
An example of the amortization of the costs for a geothermal heat pump
Assuming a household needs 20,000 kWh of heat annually, purchasing a geothermal heat pump costs around 20,000 EUR, while a new gas heating system is about 10,000 EUR. With a coefficient of performance (COP) of 4 for the geothermal heat pump and current energy prices, a sample calculation could look like this:
- The geothermal heat pump requires only 5,000 kWh of electricity for 20,000 kWh of heat, which leads to heating costs of 1,190 euros at an electricity price of 0.38 euros/kWh.
- A gas heating system would cost 2,440 euros for the same amount of heat at a gas price of 0.122 euros/kWh.
- With maintenance costs of 150 to 200 euros for the geothermal heat pump and 300 euros for the gas heating system, the total costs for the geothermal heat pump are 1,340 to 1,390 euros per year, while the gas heating system comes to 2,740 euros.
- The annual savings with a geothermal heat pump can therefore amount to up to 1,400 euros.
The payback period is then calculated as follows:
- The difference in acquisition costs between a geothermal heat pump and a gas heating system is 10,000 EUR.
- Dividing this difference by the annual savings of 1,400 EUR results in a payback period of about 7 years.
Please note that this is merely a calculation example.
Watch out for temptingly cheap offers for geothermal heat pumps
On the internet, you often come across offers for geothermal heat pumps that seem astonishingly cheap. However, caution is advised: with such bargains, the quality may suffer. The installation of a geothermal heat pump is a complex endeavor that requires specialized knowledge. It is crucial that this work is carried out by an experienced and trustworthy specialist company. This is the only way to ensure that the system operates efficiently and error-free.
The correct sizing of the heat pump is also critical. A specialist can ensure that the size and output of the pump are ideally matched to the needs of your home. This is crucial not only for the efficiency of the heating system, but also for long-term cost savings.
In addition, government requirements must be observed: Since 2024, heat pumps supported by the federal funding for efficient buildings (BEG) must achieve an annual efficiency factor (JAZ) of at least 3.0. This underlines the importance of investing in a high-quality and efficient system. A cheap model might not meet these criteria and thus cause more costs in the long run than the savings on the purchase price make up for.
Geothermal heating: An investment in the future?
Heating with geothermal energy is like utilizing an invisible, clean energy source right beneath our feet. Geothermal heating systems are a real environmental plus because they work efficiently with the earth's energy and thus contribute to climate protection. But what about the economic viability of this technology?
In a direct comparison with the popular air-source heat pump, which utilizes heat from the ambient air, it becomes clear that geothermal heating systems are more expensive to purchase and install. The reasons for this lie in the complex excavation work required for the installation. Although geothermal heating systems often have the edge in terms of efficiency, the difference compared to the air-source heat pump is not always large enough to justify the higher costs.
For homeowners who nevertheless choose geothermal energy, ground collectors could be an attractive option – especially for new construction. If there is enough space on the property, the geothermal heating system can be installed without any problems before the garden is landscaped. This allows the heating system to be seamlessly integrated into the new home without having to make major renovations in the garden later.
Overall, the decision in favor of a geothermal heating system is worth considering, especially when thinking long-term and placing value on environmental friendliness. With proper planning and taking all factors into account, it can be a worthwhile investment in a sustainable future.
How long do deep boreholes for geothermal heat pumps last?
Answer:
Deep drilling is the backbone of an efficient geothermal heat pump, and its longevity is crucial to the sustainability of the system. These boreholes are not only engineering feats, but also remarkably durable. They consist of robust plastic pipes that are carefully embedded in a jacket of a bentonite-cement mixture. This protection ensures that the boreholes remain stable and functional for decades.
The first of these deep boreholes were drilled about 30 years ago and are proof of the durability of this technology. They still function just as efficiently today as on the first day of their commissioning and continue to supply energy unabated. This consistency makes deep boreholes a worthwhile investment that makes sense not only ecologically, but also economically. They offer a reliable and long-term solution for the use of geothermal energy.
How can solar systems be used to support heat pumps?
Answer:
Yes, a heat pump can be combined very well with a solar system. This combination offers numerous advantages and can increase the efficiency of the entire heating system. There are two main types of solar systems that can be combined with heat pumps: solar thermal and photovoltaics.
Solar thermal systems use solar energy to heat water. This heated fluid can be fed directly into the heating system to support the heat pump. This reduces the energy demand of the heat pump since it has to work less to reach the desired temperature. In some system configurations, solar thermal energy can also be used to preheat the ground from which the geothermal heat pump draws its energy. This increases the efficiency of the heat pump, especially in the colder months.
A photovoltaic system generates electricity through the conversion of sunlight. This electricity can be used directly to power an electrically driven heat pump. This is particularly effective when an energy management system is used to maximize the self-consumption of the generated solar power. This can significantly reduce the operating costs of the heat pump and increase independence from external power sources.
The investment costs for combining a heat pump with a solar system vary depending on the system and the scope of the installation. However, government subsidies can significantly reduce these costs. Subsidy programs often offer grants or low-interest loans for such environmentally friendly heating systems, which shortens the payback period and increases the attractiveness of the investment. In summary, combining a heat pump with a solar system is not only technically feasible, but also economically and ecologically sensible. It increases the efficiency of the heating system, lowers operating costs, and contributes to the reduction of CO₂ emissions.
How does the cheap heating electricity tariff for heat pumps work?
Answer:
Heat pumps are known for their high efficiency, but they also require a considerable amount of electricity to operate. Therefore, it is crucial to keep electricity costs as low as possible. For this purpose, there are special heating electricity tariffs that are cheaper than standard household electricity tariffs. These tariffs make the operation of heat pumps more economical by lowering the price per kilowatt-hour.
Two important prerequisites for favorable heat pump electricity tariffs:
- Dedicated electricity meter: The heat pump must have its own meter. This makes it possible to precisely measure the electricity consumed and bill it at a special rate.
- Controllable consumer units: It is necessary for the grid operator to have the ability to switch off the heat pump for a few hours a day. These so-called off-peak times help to relieve strain on the power grid. To ensure that sufficient heating water is still available during these times, a buffer storage tank is necessary.
Comparing is worth it: The conditions for these special tariffs can vary. It is therefore advisable to compare offers from various energy suppliers to find the best value for money. This can lead to significant savings in the long term and make the operation of your heat pump even more efficient.
Share
Download as PDF
Print page
